Understanding your direct labor contribution is a key element of your growth strategy framework. Labor efficiency ratios are powerful tools to accomplish this as they leverage quantitative means to consider how efficient and effective your current staffing model is. Through this, you have the insights necessary to optimize both labor costs and utilization.
By looking at these ratios you can:
· Identify and correct inefficiencies in your labor force
· Make informed decisions about staffing levels, compensation and overall labor costs
· Bolster your company's effectiveness
· Improve your bottom line
· Achieve your growth goals
What Does Your Pyramid Look Like?
Senior staff, such as managers and team leads, typically command higher salaries than junior staff, and therefore, having too many senior staff can significantly increase a company's labor costs. On the other hand, having too few senior staff can lead to quality problems, as junior staff may not have the necessary skills or experience to effectively manage projects or teams.
One way for companies to achieve the right balance is to analyze their consulting pyramid. This is a visual representation of the proportion of staff at different levels within a company. Typically, the pyramid is shaped so that the majority of staff are at the junior level, with fewer staff at the senior level. By analyzing the shape of their consulting pyramid, companies can identify whether they have too many senior staff, which would indicate that they are overstaffed, or too few senior staff, which would indicate that they are understaffed.
Lopsided pyramid? We can help.
Book a Call With ALTA Today
4 Key Ratios to Use in Your Growth Strategy Framework
1. Labor Utilization Ratio
The labor utilization ratio is a metric that measures the efficiency of a company's direct labor force by comparing the gross margin dollars generated to direct labor costs incurred.
The formula for this ratio is: Gross Margin / Direct Labor Costs = Labor Utilization Ratio
A ratio of 2 means that for every dollar spent on direct labor, the company generates $2 in gross margin dollars. If this ratio decreases and revenue stays the same, it could indicate that direct costs have increased, specifically consultant costs. This suggests that the firm may be becoming less efficient as each dollar spent on consultant payroll is not producing the same gross margin as before.
However, if revenue increases, it may be necessary to add more consultants to meet demand, but the labor efficiency ratio should still hover around 2. This metric can be used as a barometer to determine the effectiveness of a consulting staff and whether they are driving enough gross margin dollars based on historical data. In services industries, it is difficult to achieve a ratio higher than 2, but a ratio around 2 is considered optimal. It helps to assess whether the consulting staff is being optimized effectively. By identifying these issues and taking steps to address them, a company can reduce its labor costs and improve its bottom line.
2. Management Efficiency Ratio
The management efficiency ratio is a metric that measures the efficiency of a company's management team by comparing the total cost of management labor to the gross margin dollars generated.
The formula for this ratio is: Gross Margin Dollars / Total Cost of Management Team = Management Efficiency Ratio.
For example, if for every dollar spent on the management team, $4.32 in gross margin dollars is generated, your management efficiency ratio is 4.32. A ratio greater than 1 indicates that the management team is generating more gross margin dollars than it is costing the company.
If this ratio decreases, it may indicate that the company has added a lot of management staff, which has led to an increase in management labor costs. This could mean that the efficiency of the management team, in terms of generating gross margin dollars, has dropped. On the other hand, if the ratio increases, it could indicate that the company does not have enough management staff to support its growth.
It is important to note that this ratio should be evaluated over time and in relation to industry standards. In some cases, a lower ratio may be acceptable if the company is in a high-growth phase or the industry standard is lower.
3. Sales and Marketing Efficiency Ratio
The analysis of efficiency ratios can also be applied to a company's marketing and sales spend. By adding up the costs for marketing and sales, including labor costs, and comparing this to the gross margin dollars generated, a company can determine its sales and marketing efficiency ratio.
The formula for this ratio is: Gross Margin Dollars / Total Cost of Sales and Marketing = Sales and Marketing Efficiency Ratio.
For example, if the total cost of sales and marketing is $1.1 million and the gross margin dollars generated is $4.75 million, then the sales and marketing efficiency ratio would be 4.32. By tracking this ratio over time, a company can evaluate the effectiveness of its sales and marketing organization.
4. SG&A Ratio
Another way to assess the effectiveness of sales and marketing is to use the SG&A (sales, general and administrative expenses) ratio. This ratio compares the company's overhead costs to its revenue.
The formula for this ratio is: Total SG&A / Total Sales Revenue = SG&A Ratio
Good service firms generally have a ratio of 25% overhead staff and 75% revenue staff. If a company has 25% of its people in overhead but their compensation is too significant, this can be determined by looking at the SG&A ratio. By comparing the SG&A expenses to the gross margin dollars produced, a company can assess whether it is optimizing its overhead costs and whether they are driving enough gross margin dollars based on historical data.
In addition to the four listed above, there are many other labor efficiency ratios that companies can use to reduce and optimize their costs. For example, the turnover rate ratio can determine how often employees are leaving the company, identify why they are leaving and take steps to retain them. The absenteeism ratio can determine how often employees are absent and why and then take steps to reduce absenteeism.
Another key point to consider in getting direct labor contribution right is the type of projects that a company is working on. If a company is working on projects that require a high level of expertise, then it may be necessary to have a larger portion of your staff be senior. On the other hand, if you’re working on projects that are more routine or straightforward, then having more junior staff members makes more sense.
Using some of these ratios to get a holistic look at labor expenses allows you to recalibrate how you’re hiring and staffing projects, resulting in optimizing profits and creating a sustainable platform from which to grow your business.
Assessing the ROI of Professional Services
The same concepts you’d use to effectively manage direct labor would also be applied as you invest in any kind of professional services. Here, you want to be disciplined and thoughtful about what your expected return on investment is for professional services initiatives. Let’s say a company wants to invest resources (e.g., money, time, personnel) in a growth initiative - $121,222 in their marketing efforts.
This injection is expected to produce at least half of the spend as operating income, a 50% return on investment (ROI). The net operating income increases from $63,457 to $124,068 as a result. This example illustrates how companies can launch capital initiatives, whether it’s a new product, new service line, new hires, or marketing campaigns, as a catalyst for growth. The most important concept is that you have a clear idea of what this endeavor is expected to deliver in terms of net income so you can analyze and understand the ROI.
Power Your Growth Strategy with ALTA Consulting
Companies that take the time to consider their direct labor costs and utilization, as well as the ROI of their professional services investments are better positioned for sustainable and profitable growth. At ALTA Consulting, we can help you optimize your staffing and compensation strategies to achieve optimal results.
Take the first step: Book a call with us today to get started!